Please see attached topic for this assignment and write up your critique based on the guidelines provided below: 

Critique your assigned classmate’s Response. Prepare a writeup of no more than 200 words. In your Critique, comment whether you agree with your classmate’s choice of study design and their justification for it:

 Do you think their chosen target and source populations are reasonable? Were their exposure and outcome definitions clear? Comment on whether the stated comparison groups are appropriate for the chosen study design. Also state whether or not their chosen measure of disease frequency and measure of association are appropriate for the study design. If and when you disagree with your classmate’s response, please provide your rationale. 

When providing your critique, include both strengths of the Response as well as areas that provide an opportunity for improvement.